Would Austin voters approve an MLS stadium deal?

Columbus_crew_stadium_mls_allstars_2005.jpg

I really can’t make sense of what’s going on with the Columbus Crew. Apparently somebody else might buy them and keep them in Columbus. And then we’ll get an expansion team. Someway, somehow, though, Austin will get a third-rate professional sports team.

IndyAustin, with the help of some donors who have a financial interest in halting the construction of a new soccer stadium, is gathering signatures to try to annul the stadium deal approved by Council in August. The petition calls for voter approval and a super-majority support on Council before the city can give away public land to a for-profit business.

I assume that valued AustinPolitics.NET reader Linda Curtis will succeed in gathering the necessary signatures because a) she has the time and money to do it and b) 30,000 signatures is nuthin. People will sign anything to get you out of their face.

So assuming the proposed ordinance went into effect, the stadium deal would have to clear two bars. It would need support from nine of 11 Council members and then be approved via referendum by voters.

It didn’t get super-majority support from the current Council, but two of the four CMs who voted against are retiring, and I think they’re relatively likely to be replaced by people who would either support the deal or could be convinced to support it. Furthermore, I think if a CM is on the fence they would be inclined to vote yes and “let the people decide” then be the deciding vote that stops the deal in its tracks.

The next question: Would Austin voters approve the deal? I really have no idea. It really depends how both sides run the campaign. A few thoughts though:

A) Most people don’t care whether an MLS team comes to town. It’s the MLS. It’s not even the most popular soccer league in the U.S. (that honor goes to Liga MX).

B) Thankfully, people are increasingly wary of subsidies to professional sports teams, but the Austin deal is nowhere near as bad as many other recent stadium deals. The city isn’t putting down any money, but rather forgoing future property tax revenue, some of which the MLS team will offset by investments in transit, on-site affordable housing etc.

C) It is misleading when deal opponents argue that we are forfeiting hundreds of millions in property tax revenue … that revenue would have only materialized if the city had allowed the land to be developed into exactly the type of development that those opposing the stadium tend to fight against tooth-and-nail.

D) I think the referendum vote would depend largely on how well the pro-MLS side argues that the stadium deal does not constitute a large corporate giveaway.

3 thoughts on “Would Austin voters approve an MLS stadium deal?

  1. “I assume that valued AustinPolitics.NET reader Linda Curtis will succeed in gathering the necessary signatures because a) she has the time and money to do it and b) 30,000 signatures is nuthin. People will sign anything to get you out of their face.”

    Afraid I have to disagree on this one. CodeNext opponents struggled a fair amount to get enough signatures for their own ballot initiative — this despite them using brazen propaganda to con people into signing it under false pretenses — and that was a *much* more contentious issue than this one, at least in Central Austin, as well as one that at least had some degree of substance to it.. They failed to garner enough signatures in time to get it under consideration for the May ballot as originally planned, in fact.

    IndyAustin’s referendum, on the other hand, is just plain silly, considering the city is paying nothing towards the construction of the stadium itself. Linda Curtis and her IndyAustin cohorts excepted, there’s also no significant opposition to the basic idea, so I’d say there’s very little chance it’ll ever make it onto a ballot (regardless of how the Precourt deal works out). I’d also point out that Curtis actually *doesn’t* have all that much money for this endeavor, aside from donations from COTA-tied interest groups.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s